Can the Graduate School comment on romantic/sexual relationships between faculty and students?
I heard that there was a discussion in the GPSA meeting about policies regarding romantic/sexual relationships between faculty and graduate students. There are certainly some thorny issues around consent in such relationships with imbalanced power dynamics, and I am interested to see where the GPSA and the Faculty Senate take these concerns.
Does the Graduate School have any comment on this issue, as it pertains to not only the health and safety of graduate students, but also the academic standing of graduate students (both those involved in such relationships and not) and the standing of the Cornell Graduate School as a whole?
Additionally, and more specifically, the notion that some faculty might be writing recommendation letters for graduate students in exchange for sexual favors---whether those graduate students 'consent' or not---strikes me as deeply troubling. Do you have any thoughts on this practice, or on how to change a culture that has apparently led to such behavior?
Curious Graduate Student
Thanks for writing with your excellent question!
The Graduate School supports and encourages the ongoing graduate student discussion of a new or revised policy to address romantic/sexual relationships between graduate students and faculty. The debate ongoing in the GPSA includes multiple perspectives and voices, relflecting the complexity of this issue.
The Graduate School supports the efforts of the GPSA and especially the Student Advocacy Committee (SAC) in proposing policy alternatives for discussion, presumably with the Faculty Senate when ready. In my time at Cornell (since 2012) I’ve developed an admiration for the diligence and passion of the SAC for their work identifying and addressing substantive issues on behalf of graduate students. We value their work and our partnership with the GPSA and graduate students in addressing concerns such as these.
We recognize the diversity of opinions that exist about consensual sexual relationships between graduate students and faculty, including, as you suggest, that some students may see these relationships as beneficial, e.g., exchanging sex for recommendation letters, as discussed at the recent GPSA meeting. We also recognize that perceptions and definitions of “consensual” may vary, even among the two individuals involved in the relationship.
First and most importantly, if students feel coerced or threatened or enticed into behaviors or sexual relationships with faculty, particularly where there is a power differential or an element of supervision or if promises of resources or access are made to students, we encourage students to talk to someone to get information, help, or other perspectives. Cornell has a policy on sexual misconduct and on faculty romantic and sexual relationships with students and has many offices that can help. (See the complete list below.)
Both Janna Lamey, assistant dean for graduate student life, and I are available to meet or talk by phone. In addition, there are confidential resources, such as the Ombudsman Office, that students can contact to get help and find resources.
Even in cases where students may willingly initiate consensual sexual relationships for what might be perceived as a beneficial career-building purpose (e.g., getting recommendation letters) as suggested at the GPSA meeting and in your question, there is potential for serious, damaging outcomes. In addition to possible emotional distress, such relationships exchanged for specific perceived benefit have the potential to undermine the professional identities and careers of those involved. When these relationships end, accusations of coercion, harassment and assualt or rape are sometimes made.
Your question reminded me that, while I worked in the graduate school at Columbia, the student newspaper published interviews with undergraduates who had initiated relationships with their TAs and faculty. From flattery and flirting (which garnered extensions on assignment due dates) to dates (which students reported got them stellar letters of reference) to more (which students reported got them grades of A), the TAs and faculty were made to look easily manipulated for their seeming willingness to toss aside objective standards, professional ethics, and their principles. (I just discovered that the advice I wrote to our Columbia TAs at the time is still posted: http://www.columbia.edu/cu/tat/pdfs/ta_student_relationships.pdf.)
Thanks for writing. Let’s continue this conversation.
Jan, Associate Dean for Academic and Student Affairs
Complete this form or send an email to firstname.lastname@example.org (link sends e-mail) if you need to report sexual misconduct.
Any member of the Cornell community who has experienced sexual harassment, assault, domestic violence, dating violence or stalking is encouraged to seek out confidential support.
Office of Workforce Policy and Labor Relations
Cornell community members are invited to contact this office regarding issues of harassment, including sexual harassment, and other forms of discrimination based on EEO-protected class status by Cornell staff or faculty members.
Phone: 607-255-4680, email@example.com
Cornell graduate and professional students are invited to contact this office regarding issues of harassment, including sexual harassment, by another Cornell graduate, professional or undergraduate student.
The SHARE website has many resources to help you get support in the event of sexual harassment or assault.
For 24/7 confidential consultation with a health care provider or counselor, students may call Cornell Health at (607) 255-5155